I love Hoda Afshar's portraits and videos from Manus Island (it's Australia's Refugee Devil's Island - you go in but you n...
Wednesday, 20 March 2013
Bertien van Manen's Bijou Book of Childhood
I really love Easter and Oak Trees by Bertien van Manen (and you can read all about it in next month's BJP). It's a tiny book that is a nostalgic look at childhood in the 1970s, the fun, the freedom, the nakedness, the lack of self-consciousness.
So you see her kids smoking (to follow on from yesterday's post) cigarettes made from kitchen herbs, pretending to drink and running around naked. In a way, it's a retrospective book about the wilding of childhood, but it's not done with a heavy hand weighed down by gravity, it's done in a manner that is in keeping with the idea - a manner that is light and mobile that has a charge of energy rather than the weight of the didactic.
the Guardian on Brecht and Stanislavski. It centred on the opposition of the two theories of what drama could be.
'Broadly speaking, Brecht's approach was political, Stanislavski's psychological; Brecht's epic, Stanislavski's personal; Brecht's narrative, Stanislavski's discursive. Brecht's actors demonstrated their characters, Stanislavski's became them; Brecht's audiences viewed the actions of the play critically, assessing the characters, Stanislavski's audiences were moved by the characters, identifying with them; Brecht's productions were informed by selective realism, Stanislavski's aspired to poetic naturalism.'
The theories originated from Stanislavski's observations on himself.
'Was he relaxed? Hardly ever. Did he believe in what he was doing? Almost never. But when had he been relaxed? When had he believed in what he was doing? When had he been good? He remembered certain passages of certain performances he had given. Why had they been remarkable? Generally, he discovered, because they were specific, rooted in either personal experience or memories of behaviour that had impressed him.'
The same idea can apply to photography and as soon as I read the article I thought of Bertien van Manen. She creates books that go deep beneath the surface yet still have a life that pulls you into them. They ase simple yet complex, beautiful but disturbing. In Callow's summary of Stanislavski (which is not the more intense Strasberg Method version), they are psychological, personal, discursive, moving and naturalistic. Wonderful!